Pick Punta Cana for the widest choice and the lowest resort price: TUI fly flies nonstop from Amsterdam Schiphol twice a week in about 10 hours 10, with returns from about 588 euros in December 2026 and about 678 euros in March 2027. Pick Montego Bay for an English-speaking island with a real city next to the beach: TUI fly flies once a week in about 10 hours 45, with returns from about 717 euros in December and about 692 euros in March. Note that the flight home stops once on both routes and takes about 13 hours.
OPTION A
Montego Bay
Jamaica's fourth-largest city and the tourist gateway to the north coast, with its own airport and a cruise port. White sand beaches on the eastern side of the bay with coral reefs offshore, duty-free shopping and golf at Rose Hall. English is the official language. In October 2025 the city was hit hard by Hurricane Melissa.
Return from Schiphol: from about €645 (January 2027)
OPTION B
Punta Cana
The eastern tip of the Dominican Republic, with 100 kilometres of coast on the Caribbean Sea and the Atlantic Ocean. It has more than 50 megaresorts, nearly all owned by European and mainly Spanish hotel chains. Bávaro alone has 10 kilometres of beach. The language is Spanish.
Return from Schiphol: from about €588 (December 2026)
Montego Bay vs Punta Cana at a glance
| Montego Bay | Punta Cana | |
|---|---|---|
| Nonstop from Schiphol | TUI fly, once a week | TUI fly, twice a week |
| Outbound flight time | about 10 hours 45 | about 10 hours 10 |
| Return flight | stop in Cancún, about 13 hours 30 | stop in Willemstad, about 13 hours |
| Return from, December 2026 | about €717 | about €588 |
| Return from, March 2027 | about €692 | about €678 |
| Most expensive month measured | July, from about €881 | July, from about €790 |
| All-inclusive, 7 nights for 2 (March 2027) | from about €1,875 (3 stars), 5 stars from about €2,834 | from about €1,734 (4 stars), 5 stars from about €1,994 |
| Entry on a Dutch passport | no visa up to 90 days, passport valid until departure, register arrival online beforehand | no visa, passport valid 6 more months on departure, free e-ticket |
| Currency | Jamaican dollar (JMD) | Dominican peso (DOP); US dollars in most places |
| Language | English | Spanish |
| Time difference in winter time | 6 hours behind the Netherlands | 5 hours behind the Netherlands |
| Driest month | February, about 42 mm | March, about 50 mm |
| Wettest month | October, about 159 mm | September, about 135 mm |
| Hurricane season | June to November | June to November |
| Dutch travel advice colour | yellow | yellow |
Checked November 2026
Fares are the lowest return per departure month shown by Skyscanner on 19 November 2026. Skyscanner itself calls them estimated lowest prices found in the past 12 days. They are the lowest price of any airline, so not always that of the nonstop flight. Flight counts and flight times come from FlightConnections, Kayak and TUI (November 2026).
Resort prices were measured on Booking.com on 19 November 2026 for 9 to 16 March 2027, two adults, all-inclusive, outside the Dutch school holidays. Entry rules come from the travel advice of the Dutch Ministry of Foreign Affairs and from the ANWB (the Dutch motoring and travel association).
Getting there from the Netherlands
Montego Bay
Only TUI fly flies nonstop from Schiphol to Sangster International Airport (MBJ), once a week with a Boeing 787. In November 2026 Kayak showed Tuesday as the flight day. The outbound flight covers 7,894 kilometres in about 10 hours 45. The airport is about 5 kilometres east of the centre, so the ride to a hotel in Montego Bay itself is short.
KLM does not fly nonstop. With a connection you are on the road longer: a one-stop return Kayak showed, about 644 euros with SWISS via Zurich in January, took more than 16 hours on the way out.
Punta Cana
Punta Cana (PUJ) is also nonstop with TUI fly only, but twice a week. The outbound flight covers 7,240 kilometres in about 10 hours 10. One example Kayak showed in November 2026: out on Wednesday 2 December at 09:05, arriving at 14:15 local time. The airport is about 3 kilometres inland.
Everything about the destination itself, from Bávaro to Cap Cana, is on our Punta Cana page.
Which airport, and who TUI fly is: both flights leave from Amsterdam Schiphol (AMS), the main Dutch airport, which has its own railway station directly below the terminal. TUI fly is the airline of the tour operator TUI. It sells seats on their own as well as package holidays, so you do not have to book a hotel with it.
Our guide to flying from Schiphol covers trains, parking and how early to arrive. We found no nonstop flight to Jamaica or the Dominican Republic from Eindhoven Airport or Rotterdam The Hague Airport, so the closure of Eindhoven from 1 February to 19 July 2027 does not affect this trip.
The catch: nonstop only applies on the way out. According to TUI the return from Montego Bay has one stop, which Kayak showed in Cancún, and the return from Punta Cana makes a short stop in Willemstad on Curaçao.
That makes the journey home about 13 hours from Punta Cana and about 13 hours 30 from Montego Bay, against 10 to 11 hours out. Comparison sites sometimes still label these flights as direct, so check the duration of the return leg when you book. The Punta Cana example left on Sunday at 19:40 and landed at Schiphol at 13:35 the next day.
One flight a week sets the length of your trip. To Montego Bay the nonstop flight only allows 7 or 14 nights. With two flights a week Punta Cana gives more room: a short week or ten or eleven nights also works. If your leave dates are fixed, check the flight days first and choose the hotel after that.
The sum: two people, one all-inclusive week in March 2027
We took the lowest fare for March and the lowest all-inclusive price per star class Booking.com showed for 9 to 16 March 2027. Transfers, tips and excursions are not included.
- Punta Cana, five stars: about 3,350 eurosFlights 2 x 678 euros is 1,356 euros. Resort, 7 nights all-inclusive, from about 1,994 euros.
- Montego Bay, five stars: about 4,218 eurosFlights 2 x 692 euros is 1,384 euros. Resort, 7 nights all-inclusive, from about 2,834 euros.
- Montego Bay, three stars: about 3,259 eurosFlights 2 x 692 euros is 1,384 euros. Hotel, 7 nights all-inclusive, from about 1,875 euros.
In March the ticket differs by about 14 euros per person, so it decides nothing. The resort does: five star all-inclusive starts about 840 euros a week lower in Punta Cana than in Montego Bay. Add the flights and the gap is about 868 euros for two.
Punta Cana is cheaper at the bottom end too: the cheapest all-inclusive resort we saw there, a four star, cost about 1,734 euros, against about 1,875 euros for a simpler three star hotel in Montego Bay.
In the first results Booking.com showed, Punta Cana ran from about 1,734 to 2,923 euros a week for two and Montego Bay from about 1,875 to 5,976 euros. Compare the tour operator's package price as well: flight, transfer and resort are then in one amount. More on timing is in when to book flights.
Price and weather by month
| Month | Montego Bay, return from | Montego Bay, high and rain | Punta Cana, return from | Punta Cana, high and rain |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| December | about €717 | 30.2 °C, 81 mm | about €588 | 29.4 °C, 91 mm |
| January | about €645 | 29.8 °C, 77 mm | about €688 | 28.5 °C, 85 mm |
| February | about €689 | 30.0 °C, 42 mm | about €686 | 29.0 °C, 63 mm |
| March | about €692 | 30.5 °C, 59 mm | about €678 | 29.0 °C, 50 mm |
| April | about €706 | 31.4 °C, 64 mm | about €684 | 29.8 °C, 65 mm |
| May | about €701 | 32.0 °C, 150 mm | about €690 | 30.3 °C, 129 mm |
| June | about €710 | 33.0 °C, 86 mm | about €696 | 31.2 °C, 94 mm |
| July | about €881 | 33.3 °C, 66 mm | about €790 | 31.8 °C, 85 mm |
| August | not measured | 33.4 °C, 94 mm | not measured | 32.0 °C, 107 mm |
| September | not measured | 33.0 °C, 135 mm | not measured | 31.9 °C, 135 mm |
| October | not measured | 32.2 °C, 159 mm | not measured | 31.5 °C, 124 mm |
| November | not measured | 31.1 °C, 107 mm | not measured | 30.3 °C, 131 mm |
Checked November 2026
Prices: lowest return per departure month from Schiphol, seen on Skyscanner on 19 November 2026. For August to November 2027 we have no reliable reading. Weather: average daily high and average rainfall per month over 1991 to 2020 (NOAA), for Montego Bay and for Punta Cana airport.
Best months: February, March and April. Both get their least rain then, 42 to 65 millimetres a month, and the from-price sits around 678 to 706 euros. Worst months: September and October, in the middle of the hurricane season that runs from June to November in both countries, and wet months too at 124 to 159 millimetres.
What Dutch school holidays do to the price: schools here break up by region (north, middle, south), most families can only travel in those weeks, and long-haul fares rise with them.
This school year the government dates are: Christmas holiday 19 December 2026 to 3 January 2027, spring holiday 13 to 21 February (south) and 20 to 28 February (north and middle), May holiday 24 April to 2 May, and summer holiday from 10 July (north) to 5 September (south). If you have no children in school, fly outside those weeks.
What the table does not show: a from-price is the price for one favourable date. The typical price is higher. According to Kayak the twelve-month average was about 892 euros to Montego Bay and about 834 euros to Punta Cana, and in July about 1,264 and 1,128 euros.
Jamaica after Hurricane Melissa
In October 2025 Hurricane Melissa made landfall on Jamaica as a category 5 storm, the strongest on record to hit the island. Montego Bay was badly affected.
The Dutch foreign ministry's travel advice, last changed on 2 September 2026, says not everything has been repaired, especially in the west of the island. Montego Bay airport is open again and, on the November 2026 schedule, TUI fly serves it once a week.
What does that mean for your booking? Ask the hotel whether all restaurants, pools and the beach are open, and read recent reviews rather than trusting photos taken before the storm. If you travel between June and November, check for both destinations what your travel and cancellation insurance covers in case of natural disasters. Dutch policies differ on this: see our travel insurance tips.
Entry rules, money and safety
Jamaica
On a Dutch passport you need no visa for a stay of up to 90 days. According to the Dutch travel advice the passport must be valid up to and including the day you leave Jamaica.
The ANWB says 6 months after departure, so check before you book. Before departure you register your arrival online: this is the C5 immigration and customs form, which according to the ANWB you complete at enterjamaica.com.
The currency is the Jamaican dollar (JMD). The Dutch travel advice colour code is yellow: crime occurs mainly in the larger cities, Montego Bay among them, and the advice is to stay away from poor neighbourhoods and remote areas. Medical costs must be paid in cash before you may leave a hospital. Sexual contact between people of the same sex is prohibited there.
Dominican Republic
No visa here either. The passport must be valid for at least 6 more months when you leave the country. Before arrival and before departure you complete the free e-ticket at eticket.migracion.gob.do.
You receive a QR code. Air travellers no longer buy a separate tourist card: since April 2018 that fee has been included in the air fare. If you stay longer than 30 days you pay a surcharge on departure.
The currency is the Dominican peso (DOP), but most places also take US dollars. The colour code is yellow, mainly because of theft and robbery around resorts and in cities. The border with Haiti is closed.
Not on a Dutch passport? The rules above are the ones the Dutch government publishes for Dutch nationals. Visa rules and passport validity differ by nationality, so check the rules for your own passport before you book. More on cards and cash outside the eurozone is in withdrawing money abroad, and visa-free travel covers the wider picture.
Vibe: what is there outside the resort?
Montego Bay
Montego Bay is a city with a beach, not a resort strip. The white sand beaches are on the eastern side of the bay, with coral reefs offshore. Hotels are both in town, around Gloucester Avenue (now Jimmy Cliff Boulevard), and in the resorts at Rose Hall and Ironshore to the east.
There is a cruise terminal, duty-free shopping and a golf course at Rose Hall. English works everywhere. That makes Jamaica easier if you want to leave the resort, but keep the travel advice in mind.
Punta Cana
Punta Cana was built for the resort. The coast is 100 kilometres long, the water is mostly shallow and Playa Macao lies about 15 kilometres north of Bávaro. South of the village lies Cap Cana, a more upscale planned community. The islands of Saona and Catalina are a day trip and Santo Domingo is a couple of hours by road. Which zone suits whom is on our Punta Cana page.
Who is it for?
Pick Montego Bay if you...
want to speak English, want an island with a character of its own, want to get out of the resort and can travel for exactly 7 or 14 nights. Weigh the aftermath of Melissa and the travel advice in your choice.
Pick Punta Cana if you...
mainly want beach, pool and ease, want five stars at the lowest price, travel with children or a group, and want freedom in the number of nights.
Our verdict
For the classic all-inclusive week Punta Cana wins: two flights a week, far more resorts and five stars from about 1,994 euros for two. You pick Montego Bay for Jamaica itself, not for the price: the ticket costs almost the same in March, but a comparable resort is about 840 euros a week dearer in March and you are tied to one flight a week.
If you want Caribbean sun where hurricanes hardly play a part, read Paramaribo or Curaçao. If Mexico is on your list, look at Cancún, and every option for the cold months is in winter sun from the Netherlands.
Plan your trip
Travel to Montego Bay
Live flight and hotel prices, personal trip plan in 30 seconds.
Travel to Punta Cana
Live flight and hotel prices, personal trip plan in 30 seconds.
Frequently asked: Montego Bay or Punta Cana
Is Montego Bay or Punta Cana cheaper?
In March flying costs almost the same: in March 2027 a return from Amsterdam Schiphol starts at about 678 euros to Punta Cana and about 692 euros to Montego Bay (Skyscanner, seen on 19 November 2026). The resort makes the difference. A week of all-inclusive for two in a five star resort started on Booking.com at about 1,994 euros in Punta Cana and about 2,834 euros in Montego Bay, for 9 to 16 March 2027. The cheapest all-inclusive we saw was a four star resort in Punta Cana from about 1,734 euros and a three star hotel in Montego Bay from about 1,875 euros.
Can you fly nonstop from Schiphol to Montego Bay and Punta Cana?
Out yes, back no. Only TUI fly flies nonstop: once a week to Montego Bay in about 10 hours 45 and twice a week to Punta Cana in about 10 hours 10. The return flight makes a stop, in Cancún from Montego Bay according to Kayak and in Willemstad from Punta Cana according to TUI, and takes about 13 hours to 13 hours 30. We found no nonstop flight from Eindhoven or Rotterdam.
What do you need to enter Jamaica and the Dominican Republic?
On a Dutch passport you need no visa for either. For Jamaica the passport must be valid until you leave and you register your arrival online beforehand, for a stay of up to 90 days. For the Dominican Republic the passport must be valid for at least 6 more months when you leave, and you complete the free e-ticket at eticket.migracion.gob.do before arrival and before departure. Air travellers no longer buy a separate tourist card: since April 2018 that fee has been included in the air fare. On any other passport, check the rules for your nationality.
When is the best time to visit Montego Bay and Punta Cana?
February to April: both get their least rain then, 42 to 65 millimetres a month, at 29 to 31 degrees. Hurricane season runs from June to November in both countries, with September and October as wet months. July is the most expensive month we measured. For Jamaica, keep the aftermath of Hurricane Melissa of October 2025 in mind: according to the Dutch travel advice not everything has been repaired, especially in the west.
Read on
Caribbean destinations and winter sun from the Netherlands.